Kept vs Obsidian: searchable runbooks that stay on your Mac
Last updated: November 2026
Short answer: for runbooks that must not leave your Mac, Obsidian beats Confluence Cloud, because Obsidian stores notes on your device while Confluence Cloud is a SaaS product. But Obsidian is a note editor with keyword search. If you want your team to ask a question and get an answer with the exact passage cited, Kept does that on a Mac you own, reads an existing folder of Markdown, and costs $49 USD per month for one Mac, with colleagues asking from their browser.
Kept and Obsidian are not strict rivals. Obsidian is where you write and link notes. Kept is where your team asks questions of what is already written. Many teams will want both, and the sections below say when.
Kept, Obsidian and Confluence at a glance
Is Obsidian better than Confluence for searchable runbooks that don't leave your Mac?
Yes, if "don't leave your Mac" is a hard rule, Obsidian is the better of the two. Obsidian keeps notes on your device and works offline, and its pricing page says your data is stored locally and its apps do not collect telemetry. Confluence Cloud is a complete SaaS solution, so runbooks live on Atlassian's servers.
Confluence does have a self-managed option. Data Center runs on infrastructure of your choice, but Atlassian publishes no Data Center price and asks you to contact sales. It is also a server deployment, not something that sits on one Mac.
Obsidian's weak spot for runbooks is search quality and team access:
- Built-in search is keyword based. It supports operators like
file:,path:,tag:,line:andsection:, plus regular expressions. It finds files containing your words. It does not answer a question. - Semantic search is possible through community plugins. One example, QMD Semantic Search, runs fully locally, but it needs Bun and Homebrew SQLite installed on a Mac, an internet connection for the first model download, and 5 to 10 minutes of embedding time for vaults over 1,000 files. It is desktop only.
- Sharing with colleagues without Sync is manual. A third-party comparison describes local-only Obsidian as giving full ownership and zero vendor risk, at the price of manual sync and no real-time collaboration.
Confluence is stronger when you need real-time editing, permissions and Jira links. That same comparison rates Confluence strong on real-time collaboration and native Jira integration, and it advises that if fewer than 70% of the people writing documentation are comfortable in Git, choose Confluence regardless of price. That is a judgment from that author, not a measured result.
Where Kept fits: it adds the question-and-answer layer that Obsidian's built-in search lacks, and it keeps everything on the Mac. Kept can keep a folder or a Git checkout in sync, and it reads .md and .markdown files, so it can sit on top of an existing notes folder. Markdown headings become sections Kept can cite.
What tools support local knowledge base search that runs on macOS without cloud sync?
Six tools cover most of the options: Kept, Obsidian, DEVONthink, AnythingLLM, GPT4All and Ollama. They split into three types: apps that search your files, apps that answer questions from your files, and model runners you pair with one of those.
| Tool | Type of local search | Platform | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kept | Answers questions from your documents with the exact passage cited | Mac only: Apple silicon, 16 GB, macOS 14 or later | $49 USD/month or $490 USD/year, one Mac |
| Obsidian | Keyword search with operators; semantic search through community plugins | Any device, local files | Free; $50 per user per year commercial license is optional |
| DEVONthink | Databases stored locally on your Mac, with built-in AI that assists searching, and generative AI online or installed locally | Mac, iPad and iPhone | Standard $99, Pro $199, Server $499; two seats and one year of updates included |
| AnythingLLM | Document chat where no data leaves your device | macOS, Windows and Linux | Open source, MIT licensed |
| GPT4All | LocalDocs: chat privately and locally with your data | macOS Monterey 12.6 or newer; best results on Apple silicon | Open source, available for commercial use |
Ollama belongs next to these but is a different kind of tool. Its homepage describes it as a way to build with open models, locally or in the cloud. It runs the model. It is not a document library, so you pair it with an app that indexes your files.
How Kept differs from the rest of the list:
- Obsidian needs plugins and setup for semantic search. Kept is built around asking questions and showing the source.
- DEVONthink is a document manager with one-time pricing and a Server edition that lets a team use it through a web browser. Kept is a subscription focused on answers.
- AnythingLLM and GPT4All are open source and free. Kept costs money; the trade is a product built around citing runbook passages and giving colleagues browser access.
For what Kept reads and how it handles folders, see Add documents in the Kept docs rather than repeating it here.
What a team of 25 pays
Kept's price does not scale per user, while Obsidian and Confluence do once you add licenses or Sync. For 25 people, using each vendor's published prices:
| Cost line | Kept | Obsidian, local only | Obsidian with Sync | Confluence Standard |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Required spend | $490 USD per year, or $49 USD per month | $0; commercial use is not required to be paid | $0 plus Sync | 25 seats at $5.78 per user per month |
| Optional commercial license | Not applicable | $50 per user per year: $1,250 for 25 | $1,250 for 25 | Not applicable |
| Sync | Not needed; colleagues ask in a browser | Not needed | $4 per user per month billed annually: $1,200 for 25 | Included |
| Hardware | Apple silicon Mac with 16 GB | Any Mac you already have | Any device | Browser |
Obsidian is the cheapest option on paper. A third-party analysis puts the total cost of ownership for 25 users at $4,500 to $7,000 a year for Obsidian and $5,500 to $9,000 for Confluence Standard, because it counts admin time of roughly 20 hours a month for Obsidian and 10 for Confluence. Those hours are that author's estimates. Kept's cost is the subscription plus one Mac that meets its requirements.
The same analysis lists Confluence Standard at $6.40 per user per month. Atlassian's pricing page shows $5.78, and the table above uses Atlassian's figure. Confluence is also free for up to 10 users.
Who should pick which
Pick Obsidian if a few engineers write runbooks, you are comfortable in Markdown and Git, and keyword search with operators is enough. It is free, and thousands of plugins cover most gaps.
Pick Kept if the people asking questions are not the people writing the runbooks. Colleagues ask through the Mac from their browser, and each answer comes with the passage it came from. Your notes can stay in Obsidian or any other folder. Kept watches synced folders and re-reads edited files.
Pick Confluence if you need real-time editing, page permissions, or Jira links, and your documents are allowed on a vendor's servers. If they are not, ask Atlassian about Data Center.
Pick DEVONthink if your library is mostly scans, PDFs and email rather than Markdown. It supports OCR and keeps databases on your Mac.
Using Kept on top of an Obsidian vault
Point Kept at the vault folder. Kept can sync a folder or Git checkout; subfolders become categories, so runbooks/ and policies/ stay apart, and a synced folder holds up to 5,000 files. Hidden files and folders such as .git are skipped, and symbolic links are not followed.
Kept reads text, not layout: tables come through as rows of text and images inside documents are skipped. Runbooks that rely on diagrams will lose that content in answers.
Kept's own connections are narrow. Only a monthly licence check, the one-time model download and an optional update check leave the Mac. Your documents, questions and answers never do. If you connect a tool such as Claude Code or Cursor, remember that a tool running on a cloud AI sends what Kept returns to that AI's servers; use a local model to keep everything on the Mac.
Where Kept falls short
- It is not launched yet. The product page says "Coming soon" and a 14-day free trial with no card at launch.
- It needs a recent Mac. Apple silicon (M1 or newer), 16 GB of memory, macOS 14 or later and about 10 GB free. Intel Macs and older machines are out.
- One Mac per subscription. One subscription covers one Mac running Kept for one business. Colleagues use it through that Mac, so it has to be on when they ask.
- Read-only. No connected tool can add, change or delete anything in Kept. Editing happens in your own editor.
- It is not a wiki. Obsidian offers links, a graph and canvas and Confluence offers team collaboration. Kept answers from documents you give it.
FAQ
Does Obsidian send my notes to the cloud?
Not by default. Notes are stored locally on your device. Sync is an optional paid service with end-to-end encryption.
Can Kept read my existing Obsidian notes?
Kept reads Markdown files and can keep the folder in sync. Its docs say Markdown headings become citable sections; try a sample of your vault in the trial to see how your own notes come through.
How much does Kept cost?
$49 USD per month, or $490 USD per year. The plan includes one Mac, colleagues asking from their own computers, MCP and HTTP access for tools, unlimited documents and questions, and updates.
What if I stop paying?
Asking new questions pauses until you subscribe; documents, categories and past answers stay.
Does Kept replace Confluence?
It replaces Confluence only as a place to ask questions. Kept reads Confluence exports, but it does not host a team wiki or editing workflow.
Is Confluence available offline or on my own machine?
Confluence Cloud is SaaS. Data Center is self-managed on infrastructure you choose; Atlassian lists no price for it and asks you to contact sales.
Next steps
- List where your runbooks live today: a Markdown folder, a Git repo, a Confluence export.
- Check that the Mac you would use meets the Kept requirements.
- Read what Kept can read and how folder sync works.
- Try Kept on a copy of your runbooks folder when the trial opens, and ask it the five questions your on-call engineers ask most.